
My new favorite movie!
Review created: 08/02/06(updated 08/02/06)
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
I first saw this movie as a video store rental and decided right away I wanted it for my personal collection. It is currently my favorite movie, and I'm sure will continue to be one of my top favorites for a long time. This says a lot about it since I enjoy a wide variety of genres, including drama, action/adventure, horror, comedy, and anime, to mention a few. It is definately a chick flick, and would be enjoyed by those who like romantic or period movies.
What I like about it, besides its classic story line, is the scenery, the musical score, and the general grandeur of it. Many have criticized this version of the movie, 1 - for what they perceive as poorly casted roles, and 2 - for not strictly adhering to the actual dialogue of the book and cutting out too much of the story. In my opinion, the acting is very good, and Keira Knightly's performance as Elizabeth Bennet is right on. Matthew MacFadyen does a more than passable job as Mr. Darcy, and the supporting roles are portrayed reasonably well. In response to #2 above, the script writers did take a few liberties with the dialogue, not so much in what was said, but with which character said it. However, I found that this did not interrupt the flow of the story. As for cutting out too much of the story, this was a necessity in order to make a reasonal length mainstream feature film. Compared to the 6-hour 1995 A&E miniseries, which I consequently checked out from the library to make a comparison to the new release, they did leave a lot out, and I must admit that those extra few hours did make the story flow a little more smoothly. But, those extra scenes didn't make me enjoy that version more. After seeing the two, I still like the shorter 2006 version better. And I'm sure that hard-core Jane Austin fans would argue vehemently with me on that.
The only thing I disliked didn't so much have to do with the movie as it did with the particular DVD I purchased. Be sure to get the version the was released in the US. I got a version that I think was an import. There is some Asian writing embossed on the label and the box is slightly different than others I've seen, which I didn't notice until after I got it. The only difference between my version and the one I rented from the video store is the ending. My version does not include the final scene, about 1 minute, that I saw in the rental. In fact I probably would not have even missed it except I expected it to be there and, thus, was disappointed.
I highly recommend this movie to most women - I did say chick-flick - and even a few men.
Review ID: 10000000001472619

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.