
Better get out your Bibles and Torahs...

When "Yentl" was released the many thought:"let's go see Barbra Streisand and Mandy Patinkin" in that new comedy.
Yes...I heard comments close to, if not qouting this past statement, but such a statement was very far from being true, as it's intentions by the author and writer, and creator of this extremely fine play, turned movie as it was also in book form prior to that.
I found it very entertaining anf "yes", there were awkward, sort-of "funny" situations in Mr.Arthur Bechevis' Singer' story about a young Jewess who from her youth studied and read the other than picture books that she would supposedly get from the traveling Book-seller, who tried to give her "picture books" as it was a traditional Jewish thought for their females "not" to educate themselves in this manner, and although her "Papa" was a Rabbai in the community which was called a "schtettle", or some would refer to the settlements today...a "Ghetto", a Jewish ghetto, where the Jews lived together and carried on their lives in as much peace as was practicable, even though the time was just in the ending of the 19th-20th centuries.
Yentle was discouraged a bit by the fact that it was her "principle by tradition" not to be engaged in such things that were in the domain of the males of the little settlements, very much as in "Fiddler on the Roof", by Shalom Alacheim ('ch' or 'h'= pron.from deep in the throat as if to be "sucking a 'lunger' if you will (sorry~!) (A bit difficult to get used to for us with "Western European dialects").But, I'm getting better at it~!~! {:-}
Okay, the pros are the entire movie, play, and book, where we find no use of filthy language, but Mandy Patinkin's rather slender "glutts" are revealed to our audiences as "Yentl" and "Mandy" drop by the cooling waters of a local pond to cool off in said pond. (This could be said to be a humorous situation, for their traditional views of never to be viewing a naked back of a man by a young woman. (Yentl) Who after her "Papa" died much earlier in the picture, she cut her hair to a man's legnth, and went to join a "yashiva", a school of Jewish study of the Torah, Talmud, and the Jewish Bible, which are the first 5 books of the writings of "Moshe" (Moses).
She went into the school looking very much as a male, even though we realize that a woman has certain features that cannot easily be hidden with just a haircut..she pretends to be a very young student, and is up on her studies because her father would often draw the curtains so they could and would study Torah, and all other forbidden writings of Rabbinic studies in the secrecy of their home, so Yentl did have some edge on "Advigor" (played by Mandy Patinkin), and their fliendly relationship grew and grew until "Yentl" fell in love with Advigor, and his betrothed (played by beautiful Amy Irvine) started to feel herself that her feelings for Yentl were also growing! (Did I say this was NOT a comedy?)
Well, as you can tell those who complained about the movie being "not understandable" (as I had heard), and not comedic, were mislead by the "trailers" that were released by the Film Studio.
The situations were sort - of humorous, but to put ones-self into any position of the main players, were gritting their teeth rather than smiling!
I retract when I said:"this was not a comedy"..the story developed humourously, but reverently.
The "cons":non-existant I bought it, as I recorded Beta and VHS versions when on HBO and Cinemax, O-men!
Review ID: 10000000014228084

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.