Timeline (DVD, 2004, Full Frame)

I Enjoy Time Travel Movies... and this one is an OK escapist movie.

If you try to analyze it too much, like some other time travel movies, then it may not be as much fun for you!

Take the journey with the cast members and have fun with it!

Recommended for rental viewing only, not for your sci-fi collection.

This was an excellent movie. I loved it!

The movie starts out at an excavation site in Castelgard, France. They find a note dated back to 1357 from their boss, Professor Johnston, in a chamber that has been sealed since the middle of the 14th century. They know that Professor Johnston is visiting the dig's funder, ITC (a computer company), and Marek, Kate, Chris (the boss' son), Stern, and Francois go to ITC to figure out what has happened to him. They find out that ITC has accidentally discovered a wormhole leading to Castelgard during the year of 1357, and that ITC has the capabilities to send 3D objects through the hole, and that Johnston is trapped there and his only hope is to send another team after him. But ITC has a few secrets it's hiding from the retrieval team...

This movie is based on a book by Michael Crichton (Jurassic Park). It stars Paul Walker, David Thewlis, and Gerard Butler.

All in all, this is a great movie to add to your collection.

I really enjoyed this movie. I like Gerard Butler in just about anything he's done. That's mainly why I bought it. But the storyline interested me & I have to say I wasn't disappointed. From start to finish, there was something for everyone--action, adventure, romance...not a chick flick or just for guys. I would recommend it.

Exciting movie! Gerard Butler is one of my favorite actors and he is wonderful in this movie....time travel at it's best.

Frankly, I bought this movie because it had Gerard Butler in it. I collect all his movies and waited for the right opportunity to purchase this. I enjoyed it and as usual thoroughly enjoyed his performance. I recommend it to anyone who likes Gerard and that kind of movie. The acting was good and it was very entertaining. I was told it wasn't that good but frankly I enjoyed it more than I thought I would. Not one of his best but of course he was terrific.

This is 2 reviews blended in one; the first, the movie as a standalone, and the second, as an adaptation of the book.


THE MOVIE:
The movie was not very good. It moves quickly and is filled with action but suddenly dies half way through and grinds to a slow finish. They don't really take time to explain much, rather they press forward with the story and unsuccessfully try to allow the characters to explain important points as the film runs it's course.

The story is creative and could be exciting. Archaeologists go back in time to the place they had been excavating. The man who is sponsoring the archaeological dig is a bad guy, someone seeking to make money off of the scientific find of the ages, time travel, even if it costs a few lives.
The acting is OK, the direction is OK, the editing OK, the screenplay is horrible, and the costumes, landscapes, sets and period pieces are somewhat authentic although stylistic and cliche. The battle scenes are poorly choreographed and not exciting. The only thing of note that was accurate would be the siege engines. That was done well.

All-in-all, the movie is poor. It is an OK escape, a film that may be worth watching but which does little to add to the genre of action/adventure films. A below average outing.


THE MOVIE AS AN ADAPTATION OF THE BOOK:
This is where the movie really falls flat.

If you read the book, don't expect much from the movie. Everything is changed. Characters, their motivations and fears, reasoning and abilities, strengths and weaknesses, relationships and interactions with each other, are all changed from the minute the film begins. A few good characters are completely dropped and several others are significantly changed from the book. The best character from the book, Andre Marek (played by Gerard Butler) is uninteresting at best.

The plot, the scientific explanations of time travel (which the movie just explains was an accident), the historical figures, the confrontations and protagonists, are all different and lack the depth and richness they possessed in the book. This was a pathetic attempt at adapting a book to film.

The book, as usually is the case, was much better than the movie. I can accept that. The basic premise of the book is carried over; that is to say that "based upon the novel by Michael Crichton" is an accurate while also misleading description. This movie just does not maintain any similarity to the book aside from the basic premise. It was very disappointing.

I truly enjoyed the book and felt that it could have been better adapted. I don't know if Crichton (the writer of the book) was involved in the movie, but if this were an adaption of a book that I had written, I would be very unhappy with the hack job that Hollywood did on a novel that was well researched, well written and thick with character development, historical accuracy and suspense.


MY RATING:
So, to sum up; if you are looking for an adventure, set in medieval times, this may suffice as mindless entertainment. As a standalone film, disregarding the book, the movie is a 2 or 3 out of 5, if I am generous

As an adaptation of the book, I would give this a 1 out of 5, very poorly done and extremely disappointing compared to a very good book.

So, I arrive at an average rating of 2. Had I not read the book, I may have rated the film a 3, but that is a bit generous because the movie just doesn't hold up as an entertaining adventure. Sorry.

Same ole story. Going back to medieval times and fighting and running. Stuff you've seen before. And the acting was truly from the past. The story line kept jumping from place to place. I bought this movie hoping it would be something other then killing and slaughter,but it was what I got. The only really good part was the ending...which would not have happened if they had not gone back in time. Some of it was not necessary. Who comes up with this stuff?

paid for dvd on 5/25, never recieved dvd and today is 06/10/09????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

very cheap
very speedy delivery
good bargain i have been looking for this movie everywhere and then i finally found it

Loved the movie!! Everyone did!

We loved the battle sequences, and how the the battles progressed...the plotting of this movie was good, however quite transparent.

Character delineation was good, but for the girl. She was a fair actress, at best.

Save the weak points, the movie was great!

Well acted..action packed..great story line that sweeps you up and carries you along with the story...

I bought it because,, like many others,, I really like Gerard Butler. I first saw "Timeline" a few years ago and didn't care for it. If they would have followed the book more it could have been a great movie. Now that I've watched it again,, it wasn't too bad. It was exciting enough to be entertaining. I will probably watch it again when I need a "Gerard Butler" fix.

An action-packed adventure, with time travel, romance and all you could want in a great movie. This is top-notch with me and my husband.

This movie is a perfect blend of new age science with old medieval history. You won't be wasting anything- time or money- on this movie.

If you like science fiction blended with medieval era, this is a movie you will enjoy. Acting and scenery portrayed very convincing. A nice escape movie.