
But What If You Are Wrong? Don't you Want to Believe.
Review created: 08/09/09(updated 08/09/09)
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Those who are avid conspiracy theorists such as Mulder and I would perhaps always get around to posing the favorite line in the series, "Yeah, but what if you are wrong?".
The reunion of David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson with Chris Carter's direction and Mark Snow's powerful song was a long time coming. My initial feeling about Duchovny's portrayal of Mulder this time around was somewhat mixed, since he played so close to the cuff and didn't seem to have the passion of finding out the truth anymore. Scully was absolutely top-notch in this film and made you actually relate to her passions instead of being totally convinced that she always was there to play the devil's advocate. In this case, I was convinced, after all these years, that she might actually have been close to believing in something she never previously could from her scientific perspective.
We find the two going along with their own separate lives, but soon get the feeling that they were always meant to be together, except for his crazy ideals and her total stubbornness to take him at all seriously. Before the end, we somehow feel like these will probably wind up together forever, after all.
Scully seems to be engrossed in her work, but somehow isn't living a life filled with satisfaction and joy since her departure back into medicine at a Catholic hospital has yielded a very painful showdown between her credentials and her failure to believe in some other higher form of power that yields her intuition to a faith-based universe.
David, I really dug the shaggy look, but I'm also glad you decided to shave it off during the film, it makes you look more vulnerable to see your facial expressions.
When a federal agent goes missing, the pair returns to work together to decipher a psychic Father Joe's (Billy Connolly) vision who leads the team
to crime evidence which unravels a greater in depth serial killing behavior they
would not normally have spotted. Although Scully seems apparently unconvinced of any psychic tie from Father Joe and believes he is lying about his visions, she is told by Father Joe, "Don't Give Up", which seems to plague her throughout the film, since she has no idea why he had said this to her. However, it soon dawns on her that he might be seeing her fulfill a much greater role living in faith with one of her sick patients.
This 104 minute film seems to finally satisfy my curiosity about Scully's perceived inner confusion about life and lays to rest in my mind the fact that we are always trying to figure out what made her tick.
Greatly appreciated in this film was feeling actual real emotion coming from the main characters to one another, which completes the struggle between knowledge and the suppression of knowledge. We all must someday struggle within our own selves someday about the conflicting roles that science and faith may play in our decisions. I think Chris Carter spent much time in developing this theme so that he could rationalize many things about his own feelings.
I don't want to give away the criminal/paranormal ties in the movie to anyone who hasn't seen it yet, however, I will say that it seemed somewhat believable, since there have been scientific research conducted along the same lines in the past from other foreign research studies.
I'm going to give this film a 4/5 since it is one I would probably watch again sometime in the future with someone else interested in the X-files characters.
PLEASE VOTE YES TO MY REVIEW. THANKS
Review ID: 10000000013069821

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.