
Sigma/Quantaray 18-200mm OS for Canon
Review created: 02/08/09(updated 05/29/09)
3 of 4 people found this review helpful.
I scored quite a deal for the Quantaray version of this lens. Some of the Sigma lenses are rebranded into Quantaray (among other brands I think) lenses with exactly the same optics and most of their external design. Looking for these deals might be a good idea if you don't mind what the tag on your lens says and you wouldn't mind the savings!
I have had a Sigma version before and after using and selling it at one point, I missed the quality of this superzoom... and visited my buddy Mr. E. Bai. Having a superzoom is nice for obvious reasons, but when you shoot mainly a larger 1D/1Ds body, getting one for your backup cropped body will make you feel like you've been freed by the compactness. I've shot with superzooms for fullframe back in the day and these new ones are really getting better (and OS/IS/VC?!?). I think people now most often mistaken all superzooms to be too much of a trade off for image quality. Certainly, there are compromises with image quality, but it really is not that much, especially for the casual shooter (you're not going to take this out for a paid shoot anyways!) You really have to try this one out to appreciate the progress.
Anyhow, I've used similar lenses, including the Canon 18-200mm IS. I find the Sigma sharper at focal lengths I care about and better built... oh yeah, and cheaper.
Pick up a bargain one and free yourself of lenses and gear!! (at least some of the time).
**UPDATE May, 2009: Just thought I'll let everyone know that this puppy is made for 1.6x field of view crop digital bodies (50D, 1000D, 500D, etc.), i.e. DSLRs with an EF-s mount. HOWEVER, it actually has an EF mount to fit on older cropped bodies before the EF-s mount was introduced (e.g. 10D, D30--not 30D, and older). AND THE MAGIC HERE is that I have mounted it on my Canon 1Dii (1.3x crop and EF mount only) and got pretty good results from it. Correctable vignetting starts at about 24mm (this is by memory I'm afraid), where as from 18-24mm, you get a darn good wide angle but some vignetting near the extreme corners that are not correctable (black corners). This can be for effect? The biggest deal here is that there aren't many EF 24/28-200/300mm superzooms out there with image stabilizer made for fullframe cameras or the 1D (I think there is only the Tamron 28-300mm VC). So this might be a viable way to get a superzoom for a 5D, 1Ds, or 1D if that floats your cool boat... after all, 18mm to 200mm is pretty darn cool on fullframe/1.3x. Hope that helps.
Review ID: 10000000010583261

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.