
The Purpose Driven Life
13 of 25 people found this review helpful.
I was utterly revolted by this book.
When I saw the title on the best seller list, I was anxious to get the book. I had been profoundly moved by other books such as Walden, Seven Habits of Highly Effective People, and Man's Search for Meaning that discuss the relationship between Life and Meaning, which I consider the core issue of all of human existance. These books really make you dig in and look at life in a new way, and reward you with an open mind. Between the title of the Purpose book and its great popularity, I looked forward to reading it.
The very beginning of the book dashed these expectations. We are told that the world is spiritually adrift because of people's focus on the interior. Forget about your interior life, feelings, pasions, hopes, dreams, intellect. Look outside, to an unseeable, unknowable, intangible "spirit", we are told. And not just any spirit. Mot the 4500 year old spirits of the Hindus, not the spirit of the ancient Hebrews, not founding myths of the Norse, the Greeks, the Romans. And definitely not the earth-based myths of the Druids, Africans, and Asians. No, forget all the spirits of all the races of all of history, except one.
And forget all of your own personal experience, failures and hopes, joy and regrets, pain and happiness, and those of others around you. You see, the ONLY source of purpose in all of life is provided by one very specific supernatural being. And get this: the being does not actually speak of communicate. No, we need to read about it in a collection of stories written 2000 years ago. (For some reason, this sole source of Purpose stopped communicating at that time.)
And only some of these stories are true: the ones decided by a vote in an ancient Roman city two millennia ago. Other stories written during this same period about the same people are false, heretical.
It gets worse: even the official stories contradict each other. Some appear to advocate love among all men; others provide instructions for taking and managing slaves. "Thou shall not kill" shows up in some parts, while others describe bloody genocide committed to appease a vengeful god.
Fortunately, we have Rick Warren to rationalize and interpret all this for us.
So, if you are willing to disregard the entirety of your interior thoughts, mediations, memories, experiences, and seek entirely external guidance; if you are willing to disregard 95% of the historical religions, myths, and philosophies of the world; if you are not bothered by contradictory, illogical, and disconnected writings; if you can accept that all foundational writings stopped 2000 years ago; and if you are willing to give yourself over to the strong paternal direction of a single person who will interpret your Purpose for you and guide your thinking, then you may like this book.
But you will scare the heck out of me.
I was looking for something much more inclusive, and "ecumenical" in the broadest sense of the word. I'm pleased to see how the idea of Purpose resonates with so many people in these materialist and amoral times. On the other hand, I am disappointed in the narrowness of the conversation.
Review ID: 10000000000688464

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.