
2K9 Versus Live 09
4 of 4 people found this review helpful.
Take it from me, I played the heck out of both of these games.
I'll make it easy for you to decide.
Good about 2K9: Players are extremely smooth, when you make a shot it's more rewarding. It has great crowd animation. Use of joysticks on defense and offense feels natural. More rewarding dunks. Animations on players after making a basket is funny. Dunks look cooler than live and are smoother.
Bad about 2K9: Free throws are frustrating. Faces on some of the athletes are poor. Seems like the game has high contrast-it's always too bright, shots are harder to make than live 09. Announcers get on your nerves, and aren't as authentic as Live 09's. Online play is almost impossible. If a player gets traded to another team they keep the same color sweatbands. (Allen Iverson still has light blue bands from the Nuggets though hes on the pistons now). Sometimes if you're on a fast break with no one on you your player will do a layup instead of a dunk (which is frustrating)
Verdict: 2k9 is like a simluation game, though it has poor faces on some players. Simulation games can be frustrating.
Good about nba live 09: Amazing player re-creations. Amazing audio-announcers, crowd, players, everything. You get pumped when the score is close and you're the home team. The announcers are annoying, they say interesting things instead of the same repeated crap like on 2K9. It has "NBA Live 365" that updates each players "skills" everyday. So if Kobe did crappy in yesterdays game, then hes going to be updated and do crappy when you sign on to xbox live. You can literally see the sweat on their faces. FREE THROWS ARE EASIER!!!
Bad about live: Not as smooth looking as 2k9 (sometimes players kinda float up to do a layup if you hit the button way too early). The crowd is sort of laggy. Instead of pictures of the player when a players stats pop up on the screen during the game-its like a "painting" EA made up and some of them look kinda scary because they don't make their eyes big enough! Dunks aren't as fun as 2k9 because they're slightly easier to do (BUT THEY DUNK IF APPROPRIATE). Kobe's face is actually better on 2k9 sadly, so is Rajon Rondo's, Ray Allan, and Derek Fisher IMO. Some players look too skinny.
Verdict: Slightly more arcade-y, but easier to enjoy, and controls are simpler. Faces are dead-on for the most part. 3's are easier to hit too.
Review ID: 10000000009464831

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.