
Good, but not Great.

Those who are familiar with Julia Quinn's novel are also familiar with her fabulous use of wit, humor and sarcasm. Coupled with these quirks are meaningful and emotional plots that only add to the depth of the characters within her novels. To name one in particular (which is my biased favorite) is "When He Was Wicked". All in all, the Bridgerton series is what truly sets Julia Quinn apart from the rest of Romance writers (those that write historical/regency romance). In many ways she provides depth to her novels in ways that are rarely seen in such a genre. However, though her Bridgerton series in truly unparralled in its complexity and genius, "The Lost Duke of Wyndham" seems to miss the mark.
Perhaps, I can concede, I am looking for too much similarity in her novels. And yet, this novel is definitely similar. Set in similar time periods, locations, and even tone, "Lost Duke" (as I like to call it) somehow... lost its.... shall we say it's overall feeling.
Having looked forward to this novel with bated breath (for what seemed like eons), I finally seemed to regain a steady breathing rhythm upon reading. It is that very reaction, my REGAINING a steady breathing rhythm that was disappointing to me. I had come almost accustomed to Quinn's ability to take my breath away. Literally. This novel, I am sad to say, did not accomplish such a response. While reading it, it seemed as if the plot and characters were rushed. Yes, I am aware that there is another novel that takes place simultaneously, and perhaps that is the very reason for one feeling unsatisfied. Many bits seemed to be missing throughout the novel, with scenes quickly moving as one neared the end. The beginning of the story evokes a lot of interest and emotion, however it seems to wane progressively and drastically toward the end, till the reader almost doesn't care WHAT happens to the characters. In fact, the characters actions in many ways seemed strange and well, out of character. For example, when Thomas (the man raised as the duke) kisses the main female character it just seems unrealistic. In fact, I felt like it hurt the story in many ways. As if it was an attempt to prolong and add to the dilemma at hand. Yet, even that action lacked substance. I didn't believe it for a minute.
In addition, (Spoiler) - The main male character's inability to read seemed well, false in many ways. In another way it seemed like a book I had already read. And truly, the whole novel seemed to be a replica of some other novel.
All in all, it is a good read. But it is not a great read. I do not have many hopes for the following book (it's twin). But, I believe Thomas's story is much more interesting. So, perhaps I will be pleasantly surprised. In the meantime, I will not hold my breath!
Review ID: 10000000007963274

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.