
RHI, the REAL Rascals
2 of 2 people found this review helpful.
Pros: Excellent short films which are timeless in how they portray the innocence and joy of childhood. The packaging is wonderful, although individual slim cases for each disk would have been better. The disks are replicated, manufactured in a disk pressing plant, not dvd-r disks bound to degrade and fail in a short amount of time. Menus are easy to access, giving the ability to "play all" or choose single films for play. Bonus interviews and commentary are nice, but missing the Leonard Maltin intros found on the Cabin Fever set. Leonard is King, the fan's fan. In spite of issues I list below, it is nice to have this many Our Gang shorts within arm's reach.
Cons: Once more, "restored and remastered" is a phrase to be taken with a pound of salt. Today it is little more than a sales gimmick.
"Complete" should have been modified to say, "Complete Talkies," or something to indicate that 85 of the 88 silent shorts are not included.
No subtitles/closed captioning. This have been helpful on the earlier shows, where the sound quality is not the greatest and dialogue is muddled.
Technically, the quality does not make this issue the set to end all sets. Too many shorts are low-quality Blackhawk film dubs. Who has the masters and why weren't they used? Ghosting is noticeable to these eyes at times, with occasional artifacting, although I've seen worse offenders. I viewed these dvds on an HD television, so your mileage may vary regarding the defects. The transfers would have benefited from a higher bit-rate capture, in my opinion. Dialogue and sound effects are noticeably missing in spots, i.e. "Boxing Gloves." Picture quality is comparable to the Cabin Fever release (an entirely worthy set for the occasional nostalgia viewer, or as a conduit for new fans). Completist fans should not bypass the "best of" colorized collections from another company --- their restoration efforts might surprise you.
I am mostly satisfied with this collection, however, I regret that RHI's effort lacked the superior quality that was hoped for. Full restoration on 80 shorts would have been quite the achievement. Perhaps no studio is equal to that task. It may be quite awhile before we are privileged with a do-over.
Review ID: 10000000013298130

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.