
A Battle Of Wits; It's Not
Review created: 07/14/07(updated 08/18/07)
3 of 3 people found this review helpful.
Arrogance meets Cocky when Academy Award Winner Anthony Hopkins and Oscar Nominee Ryan Gosling match wits in the entertaining and ridiculous legal thriller 'Fracture'.
On the defense side of the aisle is Hopkins, as imperious Aeronautical Engineer Ted Crawford, who admits he shot his wife but still expects to get off. For the prosecution is Gosling; smug Los Angeles Assistant District Attorney Willie Beachum, a man who doesn't like to lose, but who needs to wrap up the case quickly so that he can start his new cushy corporate job.
It would be a terrific setup, if it were possible to care about either character and if the story didn't so quickly unravel into the completely unbelievable.
The drama never gets better than in its opening scenes as it sets up the attempted murder of Crawford's Wife Jennifer (Embeth Davitz), as well as his motivation in wanting her dead.
Director Gregory Hoblit ("Primal Fear", "Frequency") keeps the suspense taut, so even though anyone who has seen the trailer knows what is about to happen, the event is still shocking. The introduction of the SWAT Team and Hostage Negotiator Rob Nunally (Billy Burke) add another layer of intrigue. It's only when the plot is actually enjoined — when Crawford is arrested and Beachum assigned to the case — that the movie falls apart.
"If you look close enough, you'll find everyone has a weak spot," is the movie's tagline, echoing what Crawford tells Beachum during their first meeting. Screenwriters Daniel Pyne and Glenn Gers should have taken that bit of dialogue to heart and scoured their own script for its weak spots. There are plenty as they have put together a courtroom drama that is plotted like a soap opera trial or an old episode of 'Perry Mason'.
The trial starts almost instantaneously after the murder. In court, Crawford completely manipulates the situation and the supposedly whip smart Beachum has no answer for him (or much legal sense, since the circumstances virtually scream mistrial). Late in the movie, Beachum does not even appear to have a layman's knowledge of the American Legal System, let alone a lawyer's, as he has to consult his law books for answers on a glaringly obvious point. It is one thing to take a little bit of dramatic license; this goes way beyond that and the film suffers for it.
The film's biggest weakness is not the haphazard and poorly structured plotting, but Beachum himself. As portrayed by Gosling; a lazy performance that offers none of the nuance that characterized his Independent Spirit Award-Winning turn in "Half Nelson", Beachum is arrogant, narcissistic, and used to winning. He is someone who has carefully managed his career and his caseload so that this graduate of a No-Name Law School could join the boys and girls of the Ivy League at a cushy Corporate Firm. He is not a drunk nor is he incompetent. There is nothing in his makeup that explains his miscues in court, adding another layer of implausibility to the story.
Beachum also is not particularly likeable and neither is Crawford, as Hopkins offers yet another variation on his Hannibal Lecter Character, albeit one not as charming as that gourmand Serial Killer. With no rooting interest in either man, it simply becomes a case of Good vs Evil.
'Fracture' does have a few points in its favor. At least, it is never dull. It has a great supporting cast; but just never delivers it's promise as a film.
What Ought To Have Been An Engaging Battle Of Wits; Simply Isn't....
Review ID: 10000000004016860

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.