
Downfall (DVD)

I bought this on the recommendation of a friend whose judgement I trust. He was right as far as he went.
The producer does an excellent job recreating what is known about the final days in the Fuhrer bunker and the defence of Berlin in April and May 1945. The scenes in which the Goebbels euthanize/murder their children before committing suicide are particularly powerful and well-acted, although the entire cast does an excellent job.
Unfortunately, the producer and writers cop out shamefully and distort the historical record in the final scenes. They show our heroine, wearing a German uniform, walking silently through a crowd of Red Army soldiers who all let her pass unmolested. The next scene shows her riding a bicycle happy and carefree in some unspoiled area in rural Germany.
This is not the reality of the fall of Berlin.
The producer and writers do not show Red Army soldiers in Berlin gang-raping tens of thousands of German woman and girls of all ages -- nuns included -- and then murdering many of them.
They do not show Red Army soldiers in Berlin shooting Waffen-SS soldiers and other German combatants after the Germans had surrendered and laid down their
weapons.
The producer and writers mention the Nazi persecution of Jews in the closing credits, but no mention is made in the closing credits that at least some of the women on Hitler's personal staff (including, possibly, our heroine) were raped by Red Army soldiers after the end of the battle, and that at least some of the women on Hitler's staff were kept as "personal prisoners" by individual Red Army men for months after the end of the war.
There is also no mention of the fact that thousands of German civilians died of starvation, exposure, disease or cold in the first two years of the Allied occupation, and that this was due in large part to Allied policies that specifically prohibited the importation of food products into occupied Germany.
This is a fascinating movie to watch and surprisingly effective in portraying Hitler's charismatic hold on many "true believers" even when it should have been clear to everyone that his mistakes and misjudgements had destroyed Germany, but Cornelius Ryan's classic work, "The Last Battle," is a far more objective account of the subject of Hitler's last days and the fall of Berlin.
Great entertainment but badly flawed as history,
Review ID: 10000000014883406

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.