
Swallow and Follow?
0 of 1 people found this review helpful.
I bought this book for school and have been struggling to get through it because of its blatant bias and unacknowledged self contradictions! I was looking forward to a thoughtful historical and evenhanded critical analysis of this very important issue. Instead the authors clearly believe that money for healthcare is limited and scarce (but we can afford to pay Kelsey Grammer a million dollars per episode of Frasier?!) and therefore that the government should take over all healthcare management to control costs (what about the $600 toilets seats the government's GAO office was buying a few years back?!) and to increase efficiency (when did the government become efficient?); and that only the Democrats will get us to this efficient, cost-effective centralized government plan. (that may be true). They also assert that doctors are only out for profit and their incomes should be limited. So we can pay a couple of million dollars per football player who is an entertainer; but a person who stands for untold hours doing delicate surgeries, or delivering newborn babies, or balancing chemotherapy regimens to kill cancer without killing the patient - this person is the one who should have a salary cap? Further the authors believe that the government should dictate how many doctors of how many specialties in how many square miles there should be. Further it purports to promote universal access to healthcare but it only means primary care medicine. A system of rationing would be in place to limit care to those with "excessive" needs for technology or support. (Watch out transplant candidates, premature newborns and open heart surgery patients!) It is more disheartening to see the failures of logic that the authors do not seem to perceive in their own content. A very patronizing and deceptive book.
Review ID: 10000000007875350

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.