
Science is now Dated; and Too Much New-Age Religion
Review created: 12/20/08(updated 05/11/09)
3 of 7 people found this review helpful.
Carl Sagan's "Cosmos", originally released in 1989, is now well over 20-year-old material, and astronomy has moved on a long way since the eighties.
Based on the television series of the same name, Cosmos' scope and focus is good, although the graphics are now unfortunately dated. Thus the series can best be recommended as a sort of historical astronomy primer: it is definitely not cutting edge. Sagan does have a captivating way of presenting the complex concepts of astronomy, and his enthusiasm is contagious. That's the best part. He got a lot of folks interested in science rather than skateboards.
On the other hand, I find the heavy mixture of his religious ideas into the material annoying. The repetitive "We have all evolved from goo yet are now on our way to becoming gods who control the universe!" paradigm is hidden religious content presented without the presence of any contrary position. Such assumptions as alien evolution, human space & time travel, and 'what-if' human evolution are other wild leaps that I have difficulty stomaching in what is billed as educational/scientific material. Such speculation is actually new-age propaganda that's being transmitted under the radar. So far, there just isn't any science behind these ideas, just the assumption that since we're here, we must be evolving into gods!
Let's just stick to the facts of science for now: When science can explain why Polonium halos exist in granite, why no supernovas have yet sterilized earth, why the helium content of the atmosphere is still increasing, why there are no transitional fossils, why the salt content of the oceans is so low despite a yearly increase, why human DNA continues to rapidly unravel at the ends (yet we're here), why it would take 600 beneficial mutations per generation to go from chimp to man in 2 million years (then find a mate with the same), why the sun continues to shrink yet was 'perfectly safe' 3 billion years ago, why the mathematics of evolution are absolutely totally mind boggling (an exponent of SIX digits!!!) - then I'll believe the assumptions behind your religion Carl.
Review ID: 10000000009856418

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.