
The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger

I did not like this novel. It was immature, depressing and filled with foul language. There was, however, exactly two redeeming qualities, which I will get to.
First of all, something is terribly wrong with Holden. I suspect that the entire novel is based upon a first alcoholic binge. Holden is a drunken and stupid extrovert. He knows that he is fairly stupid (not as brilliant as either his dead brother Allie, his prostitute writing brother D.B. or his young sister Phoebe), yet he knows he is more intelligent than most other people.
Holden recognizes "phoniness", or superficiality everywhere but within himself. He is incessantly on the phone setting up meeting after meeting with girls and friends. He would probably go insane if he had to spend one day alone with his own thoughts. The entire novel takes Holden's encounters with others one after another in a crazy break-neck speed. It is a bit ridiculous.
The beautiful thing about Holden is his youthful cynicism and his sensitive intelligence. Holden seemingly by chance stumbles upon many epiphanies. He sees through the material world into the heart of reality. He feels sorry for everyone. Everything depresses him. Nothing attracts him in the material world. In his rebellion and cynicism he unwittingly finds wisdom and sagacity—fairly useless things in a modern society.
I must give an answer to Holden's statement that Jesus' disciples were as useful to Jesus as a hole in the head before crucifixion (afterwords they of course built the Body of Christ), and that Jesus picked the disciples at random.
Holden said that he likes anyone in the Bible better than Jesus' disciples because they kept letting Him down. Arthur Childs only response to Holden on this matter was that he didn't read the Bible or go to church and that if he didn't like the disciples, he didn't like Jesus. That is not an answer!
My response to Holden would have been that nothing is random and everything is random. Jesus picked His disciples so that they might be an example. They mirror all followers of Christ—we are useless to Him as they were. If we don't like the disciples, it is not Jesus that we don't like as well, but it is ourselves.
No doubt the disciples realized their erring ways after His crucifixion (especially after He visited a few of them through the walls) and tried as best they could to mend their uselessness.
Now. It was well worth wading through all the nonsense adventures that Holden had, with his little witticisms now and then, to come to the speech of the "flit" and intellectual, Mr. Antolini (whose wife was obviously standing in as a mother-figure). Mr. Antolini could plainly see the heart of Holden's rebellion. He recommended education as the tool for Holden to explore himself. I'm not sure if I agree or not. Certainly for some people, but I doubt we should have Frank Herbert's "Dune" had he not dropped out and and pursued his own interests...
Listen now to Mr. Antolini's words, and beware of him standing over you in the dark, salivating...
"This fall I think you're riding for—it's a special kind of fall, a horrible kind. The man falling isn't permitted to feel or hear himself hit bottom. He just keeps falling and falling. The whole arrangement's designed for men who, at some time or other in their lives, were looking for something their own environment couldn't supply them with. Or they thought their own environment couldn't supply them with. So they gave up looking. They gave it up before t
Review ID: 10000000013131835

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.