
Not what I hoped it would be
Review created: 04/15/09(updated 09/21/09)
I decided to purchase this lens after reading many reviews stating it was much better than 'kit' lenses, etc. I was looking for something with a range that was a bit more telephoto than other Canon crop sensor options like the 18-55 or 17-85, and lower cost. I found this lens fast to focus, light and small to carry, and convenient to use.
On the downside I just wasn't able to get sharp, high contrast photos with it. With my 17-55 f/2.8 lens I frequently get images that are crisp with amazing detail, even wide open. With the 28-105mm it never happens, even at f/8. It is in a different league price wise (cheaper) from lenses like the 24-105L, but its performance is lower too. Maybe I just got a bad copy that had seen some issues (I purchased it used). Another downside was a loose fitting lens hood. Never fell off, but didn't have the tight fit of other lenses I own. Finally, I found the lens to be a bit wobbly when extended.
Review ID: 10000000011627198

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.