
A thousand-plus page book on CD?
Review created: 10/21/06(updated 10/21/06)
4 of 4 people found this review helpful.
Let me be clear: While I have read "Atlas Shrugged" probably 5 times, I have never heard it on C.D. Ayn Rand was a philosopher as much as a novelist, and in the book she brillantly brings to life the contrast between differing character traits which Aristotle discussed rather dryly in his "Nicomechean Ethics." Miss Rand truly loved truth, justice and the American way, though she was born and raised in Russia. She also understood it better than many if not most Americans.
I write this review merely to warn the listener of a c.d. that it is inconceivable that a 10-hour disk set can contain even a small percentage of her most insightful and fundamental concepts. Character John Galt's radio speech near the novel's end itself is 60 pages long, explaining the relationship between the far-seeing producer and a mere user of goods, and expresses an objective thinker's dissection of familiar religious concepts. For those who rely on faith, her dissection will be useless, and is definitely heresy. For those who embrace socialism and its sister communism, her words are the death knell.
However, if all you want is entertained, 10-plus hours of "Atlas Shrugged" should do it. The story is truly fresh and original.
As far as the novel itself and the story, Miss Rand persisted in her theme of individuality as illustrated in her earlier works, "The Fountainhead," and "We The Living." While I find her philosophy priceless, as I have aged I have found that there is one serious area which she does not address at all, and was rarely a high priority for her: children. She had no children, and in her books, her characters mostly remain childless. This certainly enlarges their sphere of freedom to act. And they remain childless despite acts of intercourse before birth control was a widely used practice. This in and of itself has troubling ramifications that despite her prescience she did not anticipate.
Many people grumble about her writing style but that is like someone who drives a Ferrari Testarossa and while driving 220 mph, grumbles about the car's color. The woman absolutely does not let the guilty off the hook. Her intransigence in identifying those who harm and take advantage of others' of good will in a vast variety of ways without gratitude, acknowledgment, or repayment makes this a compelling moral tale which clearly illustrates why justice is not merely a moral commandment, but a moral imperative.
I have read many philosophers; she stands head and shoulders above them all. Reading her book I believe entitled "Objectivist Epistemology" deals far better with the basics of how we understand what we know, and in contrast to Emmanual Kant's cant and Plato's "forms," when you finish reading her, you have actually learned something useful, not merely something to impress your friends with as being esoteric. Her books of her essay collections also deal with many specific topics with laser-precision and cleanliness. That woman can untie a can of worms more cleanly and quickly than anyone else I have ever read. The essays are a pleasure to read and introduce many exciting concepts in and of themselves.
"You have seen the Atlantis they were seeking, it is here, it exists -- but one must enter it naked and alone, with no rags from the falsehoods of centuries, with the purest clarity of mind -- not an innocent heart, but that which is much rarer: an intransigent mind -- as one's only possession and key."
Review ID: 10000000002163990

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.