
A New Age 12-Step Program For Artists
Review created: 09/20/06(updated 09/20/06)
2 of 2 people found this review helpful.
I was enthusiastic about this book during my first reading of it; some of the concepts presented in the book really resonated with me. The author recommends daily journaling, which is something I do anyway. Also, the idea of “artists dates” appealed to me.
Upon re-reading the book I have changed my favorable opinion of it. I now realize that there are many harmful things that I initially overlooked.
The first thing that I think is harmful: It seems to me that Cameron advises artists to pretty much squash their “inner critic” flat. While this might be a good idea for an artist who is so blocked that (s)he can’t produce any work at all, I think it is dangerous advice for a working artist who is already successfully creating. Personally, I know that the drive to satisfy my “inner critic” is part of what makes my art good. My inner critic is a real slave-driver, and she has high standards. As tempting as it would be to just make her go away, that would have a negative effect in the outcome of the quality of my art. In the long run I think it is more productive to learn to nurture your inner critic and satisfy her demands than it is to trample her.
Another harmful thing about “The Artist’s Way”: My impression after reading this book is that the author presumes to speak for God, and that she presents her own opinions as facts in this area. She seems to be of the opinion that spirituality and creativity are inextricably linked. I disagree, considering that I know some highly creative atheists who are successful artists. Many of the premises in this book are just plain flawed.
This book is as much about religious indoctrination as it is about creativity. I know people who have mistaken this book for a Christian book because of all the references to God that are made in it. It is definitely NOT a Christian book. It is a new age book. I would not recommend this book to anyone who doesn’t already embrace a new-age viewpoint. There are many things about the religious concepts in this book that you might find disagreeable if you don't agree with New Age philosophy. I definitely wouldn’t recommend it to Christians, nor would I recommend it to atheists or agnostics. (Truthfully I wouldn’t recommend it to anyone.) If you do read the book, please stay alert to the places in which the author presents her religious beliefs and opinions as fact.
This book has an eerie amount in common with the 12-step programs popularized by Alcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics Anonymous. There are exactly 12 chapters in this book; each of them incorporates the concept of “Recovery” in some way:
Week 1: Recovering a Sense of Safety
Week 2: Recovering a Sense of Identity
Week 3: Recovering a Sense of Power
Week 4: Recovering a Sense of Integrity
Week 5: Recovering a Sense of Possibility
Week 6: Recovering a Sense of Abundance
Week 7: Recovering a Sense of Connection
Week 8: Recovering a Sense of Strength
Week 9: Recovering a Sense of Compassion
Week 10: Recovering a Sense of Self-Protection
Week 11: Recovering a Sense of Autonomy
Week 12: Recovering a Sense of Faith
I don’t know about you, but I don’t need to recover any of these things. I think it’s presumptuous of the author to assume we’ve all lost our senses of compassion, integrity, strength, faith(etc.)
In all fairness, the book is interesting to read & some of the exercises in it are quite creative. Overall, though, I think that this book is a waste of time.
Review ID: 10000000001889159

Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our
guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.