All Quiet on the Western Front (DVD, 1999, Limited Edition Packaging)

This is THE version of "All Quiet on the Western Front" that must be seen! Nothing else can compare (except the book). Note that this DVD format has had some enhancement done to the original film and was re-issued in 1999. Lew Ayres is fantastic and "gets it right". The film footage is quite dated but this adds to the realism. The DVD version seems to have some enhancements but a speaker system is unnecessary because it's still mono. A story with meaning behind it and fairly realistic of WWI from the common German infantry man point of view. Definately belongs in the library of a historian or militaria collector. Prior to family viewing, an adult should review the film because portions of it may be questionable for children (it's really more of a young adult upwards movie). This review is based on the movie only, I have no idea who the potential seller may be.

The first of the WWI classics. It was redone several decades later by Richard Thomas and Ernest Borgnine.

This is an excellent rendition of the novel. It develops the pathos, futility and mindless slaughter of WW1 in a very personal and intelligent manner. The cluelessness of the civilian supporters and their nationalism is also exposed brilliantly. The themes developed in this novel and brought to life in this movie are timeless and are just as relevant to our soldiers in Iraq and Afganistan as they were to the trench bound troops of WW1. Wars are not fought by the politicians who start them and the lives of young soldiers become meaningless and disposable. This is the best way to experience war; vicariously, through an intelligent, sensitive and articulate young man who managed to keep enough love of his fellow men alive to write this for us. This should be made into a play and politicians should have to act the part of the soldiers for a year on Broadway before being allowed into office.

Story is great and from all that I've read about the period it's really quite accurate. Always loved Lew Ayres' acting, he's excellent in this movie as well as Johnny Belinda.
I've seen this movie at least 4 times and will probably watch it again and again.